While the potential for AI to transform customer experiences is clear, few insurers seem to have reached the necessary level of technological sophistication. What’s holding them back?
Simon Smallcombe: There are a few reasons. The first is a degree of caution – insurance companies are traditionally run by actuaries and accountants, and by nature they’re risk-averse. Investing heavily in new technology or re-organizing core systems can feel daunting when the return on investment isn’t immediately visible.
There’s also underinvestment in some cases, as leadership teams balance short-term profitability with long-term transformation. Replacing legacy systems or building a single source of truth for customer data requires significant capital, and not all C-suite executives feel empowered to make that call; especially in markets where executive turnover is high.
That said, we’re now seeing positive momentum. Advances in AI and lower-cost deployment models are reducing barriers to adoption. Many insurers are running proof-of-concepts of MVPs for AI agents and claims automation that are already demonstrating measurable value.
Where does the ‘human in the loop’ fit within this increasingly AI-infused ecosystem?
Simon Smallcombe: Insurance remains at its heart a very human and emotional proposition to clients. People don’t wake up one morning and decide to buy life insurance on impulse. It’s often prompted by an emotional trigger such as starting a family, a friend’s experience, or a personal loss – and that emotional foundation means the human connection will always be critical.
Personalization, enabled by AI, enhances rather than replaces that connection. We’re seeing examples where customers receive personalized onboarding videos from their advisors, explaining their policies in detail – the cover, benefits and duration – in a way that feels unique and relevant.
These moments of personalization build trust and emotional connection, turning what could be a transactional experience into a relationship. They also have a measurable impact: such initiatives have significantly improved insurers’ Net Promoter Scores by turning routine policy issuance into a moment of delight and reassurance.
For simple, commoditized products like travel, mobile device or embedded insurance, customers prefer a fully digital experience for convenience and speed. However, for more complex products that involve financial planning, wealth transference or tax considerations, customers seek a trusted advisor who can guide them through their options and provide reassurance.
The same is true across the customer value chain. As you move from mass-market and mass-affluent segments towards high-net-worth clients, the more sophisticated the needs become – and the more essential the human relationship is. Those clients expect not only expertise, but also empathy and discretion that technology alone cannot replicate. Finally, technology should enable empathy to scale – delivering speed, simplicity, and personalization without losing the human connection that defines trust in insurance.
Claims are often a critical and emotional moment in the insurance journey. How can technology and human support work together to improve that experience?
Simon Smallcombe: The claims process is where the promise of insurance is truly tested – and it usually happens at a vulnerable time for the customer. Yet today it can take 10 to 14 business days to receive a decision on a health claim, even when all the required information has been provided. That delay is often caused by manual back-and-forth between doctors, underwriters and administrators.
So, there is enormous scope for improvement. AI can streamline the process by automatically ingesting medical data, flagging missing information, and enabling faster decision-making. But just as importantly, the customer still needs human guidance through that moment – someone to explain, reassure, and empathize.
Customers buy insurance for peace of mind. When something goes wrong, they want a familiar advisor or representative to help them navigate what can be an emotional, high-stress situation. This is where technology and human empathy must come together, ensuring efficiency without losing the trust and care that define the purpose of insurance.
